Tue Aug 11, 2020 4:21
UK Court Rules Facial Recognition Has Been Used Unlawfully by Police
TEHRAN (FNA)- Facial recognition was used unlawfully by a British police force and violated human rights, the Court of Appeal ruled in a landmark case.

Judges were considering two uses of the controversial technology in Cardiff, but the judgment could have an impact on its growing use in other parts of the UK, according to The Independent.

Campaigners called for "sinister" facial recognition to be banned as a result of the ruling, but national police leaders said it does not prevent it being used.

A watchdog accused the home secretary of being "asleep on watch" after the Court of Appeal found that current policies failed to properly limit how powers can be exercised by the police.

Three senior judges stated that South Wales Police had violated the right to privacy under the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR), as well as data protection laws and duties to address concerns about racial or sex discrimination.

An order published on Tuesday announced two deployments in December 2017 and March 2018, and others “on an ongoing basis … was not in accordance with the law”.

The legal challenge had been dismissed by High Court judges in September, but the Court of Appeal allowed a challenge by campaigner Ed Bridges on three of five grounds.

Terence Etherton, Master of the Rolls, Dame Victoria Sharp, president of the Queen’s Bench Division, and Lord Justice Singh agreed unanimously that police had been given “too broad a discretion” over the watchlists used to compare scanned faces against.

They noted there had not been an adequate data protection assessment, which is required by the Data Protection Act 2018, and had violated the Public Sector Equality Duty that aims to guard against discrimination.

“There was no evidence before it that there is any reason to think that the particular AFR [automatic facial recognition] technology used in this case did have any bias on racial or gender grounds,” the judgment announced, adding, “However, the whole purpose of the positive duty is to ensure that a public authority does not inadvertently overlook information which it should take into account.”

Judges urged all police forces using the “novel and controversial” in future to do “everything reasonable … to make sure that the software used does not have a racial or gender bias”.

Bridges said his human rights had been violated by the “intrusive surveillance tool”, after he was scanned at a protest and while Christmas shopping in Cardiff.

Two arrests were made in the first deployment and the second identified a person who made a bomb threat at the same event the previous year.

The High Court found that up to 500,000 people may have been scanned by South Wales Police as of May 2019.

Bridges crowdfunded more than £9,000 for the legal battle, which the High Court said was the “first time that any court in the world had considered” automatic facial recognition.

He added South Wales Police had been using the “sinister” technology indiscriminately against thousands of people without their consent.

The 37-year-old stated he was “delighted” with Tuesday’s ruling, adding, “Facial recognition clearly threatens our rights. This technology is an intrusive and discriminatory mass surveillance tool.”

Bridges was supported by the Liberty human rights group, which called for the technology to be banned in Britain.

“This judgment is a major victory in the fight against discriminatory and oppressive facial recognition,” said Liberty lawyer Megan Goulding, adding, “It is time for the government to recognise the serious dangers of this intrusive technology. Facial recognition is a threat to our freedom – it has no place on our streets.”

South Wales Police announced it would “work with” the judgment but continue to use AFR Locate software, which it said had resulted in 61 arrests so far.

Chief constable Matt Jukes added, “Our policies have already evolved since the trials in 2017 and 2018 were considered by the courts, and we are now in discussions with the Home Office and Surveillance Camera Commissioner about the further adjustments we should make and any other interventions that are required."

South Wales Police was one of only two forces using automatic facial recognition in the UK.

In London, the Metropolitan Police has started using the technology in regular deployments despite concerns about the accuracy and lawfulness of a series of trials.

The national policing lead for facial recognition, South Wales Police’s deputy chief constable Jeremy Vaughan, said there was “nothing in the Court of Appeal judgment that fundamentally undermines the use of facial recognition”.

He added, “The whole aim of facial recognition technology is to keep the public safe and assist us in identifying offenders and protecting communities from individuals who pose a risk.”

The Surveillance Camera Commissioner stated the judgment was not “fatal” to the technology but that clear parameters needed to be set on its use and regulation.

Tony Porter added, “My considered view is that Home Office and the secretary of state [Priti Patel] have been asleep on watch and should reflect upon the comments of the court and now act in the public interest."

“I urge ministers and officials to listen to the independent regulatory voices which they have appointed to consider and advise on these matters not ignore them,” Porter said.

Porter urged the government to ditch plans to “dilute” his role by merging it with fellow watchdog the Biometric Commissioner and commission an independent review of “the legal framework which governs overt state surveillance”.






Bottom top
US: 'Death to America' Chanted at Massive BLM March in Oakland

TEHRAN (FNA)- Several hundred Black Lives Matter protesters, many wearing black bloc, marched through the streets of Oakland, California, last Wednesday, shouting a chant: "Death to America!" [VIDEO]
Broken Windows, Stores on Fire in Protesters Clash with Security Forces during Rally in Colombia

TEHRAN (FNA)- Protesters clashed with security forces during a march in the wake of the Peace Week in Bogota, Colombia. One of the rallygoers was carrying a sign reading 'You are hurt by a CAI (police station) that is repaired in one day. [VIDEO]
Iran Released Images of US Carrier Strike Group Detected by IRGC Naval Drones Near Hormuz Strait

TEHRAN (FNA)- A US Navy Aircraft carrier group, including a Nimitz-Class aircraft carrier and its escorting battleships, were monitored by home-made drones of the Islamic Revolution Guards Corps (IRGC) Navy before approaching the Strait of Hormuz at the entrance of the Persian Gulf. The IRGCN later released the images taken by its drones. [PHOTOS]
US: Fires Leave Apocalyptic Scenes in Oregon

TEHRAN (FNA)- Apocalyptic scenes of charred neighborhoods in Southern Oregon after a blitz of deadly wildfires. [PHOTOS]
Bulgaria: Thousands Demand PM to Resign at Independence Day Protest

TEHRAN (FNA)- Thousands of protesters rallied in Sofia on Bulgaria's Independence Day demanding the resignation of the government of Prime Minister Boyko Borissov. Demonstrators could be seen waving Bulgarian flags and flashlights, as well as chanting anti-government slogans and scuffling with police. [VIDEO]
US COVID-19 Deaths Memorialized on National Mall as Toll Passes 200,000

TEHRAN (FNA)- Volunteers from the COVID-19 Memorial Project have placed 20,000 American flags on the National Mall as the United States crosses the threshold of 200,000 lives lost in the Covid-19 pandemic. [VIDEO]
Mourning Ceremony of Martyrdom Anniversary of Hazrat Ruqayyah (SA) under Strict COVID-19 Health Protocols

TEHRAN (FNA)- Mourning ceremonies were held in Iran to mark the martyrdom anniversary of Hazrat Ruqayyah (SA) in the lunar month of Safar, under strict health protocols amid the COVID-19 outbreak. [PHOTOS]
US: 20,000 Flags Placed on National Mall Mark COVID-19 Deaths

TEHRAN (FNA)- Twenty thousand flags were placed on the National Mall in Washington, DC in remembrance of the over 200,000 American lives lost due to complications related to COVID-19. [PHOTOS]
US Occupation of Syria Is Now Official

TEHRAN (FNA)- The United States has now sent more occupying forces into Syria in clear violation of international law.
Iranian Students Win Colorful Medals at Singapore Math Olympiad

TEHRAN (FNA)- Six students from Iran's Hormuzgan province have received one gold, three silver, and two bronze medals in the Singapore and Asian Schools Math Olympiad (SASMO 2020), provincial Education Department official Mohammad Qavidel announced on Wednesday.
Iran, Nigeria Vow to Broaden Energy Cooperation

TEHRAN (FNA)- Iran's Ambassador to Abuja Mohammad Ali Bak and Nigerian Minister of State for Petroleum Resources Timipre Marlin Sylva in a meeting in Abuja underlined the need to expand cooperation in the field of energy resources.
IRGC Warns of Harsh Response to Any US Inspection of Iranian Ships

TEHRAN (FNA)- Lieutenant Commander of the Islamic Revolution Guards Corps (IRGC) Rear Admiral Ali Fadavi warned that any US move to inspect the Iranian vessels in international waters will be faced with not only defensive, but also offensive moves by Iran.
UK Foreign Secretary Warns Second Lockdown Could Be Needed If New COVID-19 Rules Don't Work

TEHRAN (FNA)- A second national lockdown could be needed if the latest coronavirus restrictions do not work, the foreign secretary told Sky News.
Iran, Sweden Discuss Ways to Send Humanitarian Aid to Yemenis

TEHRAN (FNA)- Senior Assistant to the Iranian Foreign Minister for Special Political Affairs Ali Asqar Khaji and Sweden's Special Envoy for Yemen Peter Semneby on Wednesday conferred on ways to dispatch food and medicine to the war-hit Yemeni people.
VP: Iran to Export PCR Kits Soon

TEHRAN (FNA)- Vice President for Science and Technology Sorena Sattari said that Iran is preparing the needed grounds for export of coronavirus PCR kits, adding that the country is also increasing export of ventilators to different countries.