Medicine
Sun Aug 02, 2020 1:58
Independent Sage Expert Warns Johnson Must Close Pubs, Gyms Again to Get England Close to ‘Zero COVID’ Before Winter,
TEHRAN (FNA)- Pressure is mounting on Prime Minister Boris Johnson to restore elements of lockdown amid evidence of increased coronavirus infections, with one member of the Independent Sage group of experts telling The Independent that indoor venues like pubs and gyms should shut in an effort to reach “zero COVID”.

Professor Susan Michie’s call came after chief medical officer Chris Whitty warned that England was now “near the limit” of the restrictions which can be relaxed without losing control of the virus, telling a Downing Street press conference, “If we wish to do more things in the future, we may have to do less of some other things.”

A member of the government’s official Sage group of scientific advisers said pubs and other leisure venues may have to close in order to allow children to return safely to classrooms in September.

“It might come down to a question of which do you trade off against each other and then that’s a matter of prioritising,” Professor Graham Medley told BBC Radio 4’s Today, noting, “Do we think pubs are more important than schools?”

Fears of a breakdown of social distancing grew on a heatwave Saturday which saw “unmanageable” crowds flock to beaches on the South coast and Wales.

A new survey by pollsters Opinium found high levels of concern about a “second wave” of COVID-19, with 75 percent of those questioned saying they expected a further outbreak later this year - and almost one-third (32 percent) of these saying they believe it will be worse than the first wave.

Freshly-released minutes of a meeting of Sage (the Scientific Advisory Group on Emergencies) showed that as early as June 23 the government’s expert advisers were discussing the likelihood that relaxations of lockdown restrictions may have to be reversed in a trade-off with other priorities, such as reopening the schools. Records of the meeting displayed concerns that a summer of relative freedom could force the reproduction rate of coronavirus - known as R - above the crucial level of one at which the disease can run out of control by the time of pupils’ intended return to lessons.

“Measures should be considered in combination and cannot meaningfully be assessed individually,” said the Sage minutes, adding, “There will be trade-offs to be made when considering what measures need to be retained or reintroduced …

“There may be a need to change measures at the end of the summer in order to be able to keep R below 1 whilst proceeding with the planned reopening of schools,” it announced.

And the minutes warned, “As measures are reversed, behavioural responses will not necessarily mirror those observed as measures were imposed as a result of the different psychological context, which may include altered levels of trust, fear and anger.”

Michie told The Independent it was time for the UK government to adopt a “zero COVID” strategy for England to match those in Scotland and Ireland, pursuing the elimination of the virus from community transmission rather than accepting a certain level of infection as the pay-off for opening up business and leisure.

“If they wanted zero COVID, they wouldn’t be opening gyms,” said Michie, the professor of health psychology at University College London.

“They wouldn’t be opening super-spreader areas like indoor pubs and bars, places where people are close to each other and touching each other and shouting and sweating,” Michie continued.

She added, “We have to look at first principles. The more people you are in contact with for the longer time and the closer in distance, and the more there is going to be shouting or singing or sweating, the more risk there is. Now that we now there is aerosol transmission, it is clear that the more ventilation there is the less risk there is."

“Drinking outdoors is less risky than inside. Open air markets are much less risky, and shops which have a lot of people going through without much ventilation more risky,” she noted.

Michie said, “The government should be less short-term and less ‘wing and a prayer’ and more focused on the lessons from other countries where they’ve got COVID down and kept it down."

“We need to be in a position where we can have confidence that children can get back to school in September and businesses can reopen with confidence. If we hadn’t lifted lockdown in June we could have been looking at zero COVID in September. If we restricted those high-risk places, then by October and November when the pressures start building on the NHS, then hopefully we can get through the winter,” she added.

Former Schools Minister David Laws, now chair of the Education Policy Institute, backed calls for a trade-off between ”nice-to-do” relaxations like pub opening and the “vital” priority of getting schoolchildren back into class.

“Having schools going back and all children back in schools is going to mean a lot more social contact,” Laws told Sky News, adding, “So it is quite possible that the government will need to rethink some of its other aspirations for the autumn, and that there may have to be more social distancing in other areas.

“I think the government might have to rethink its recent attempt to nudge people who have been working at home back into the workplace, I suspect that many people who use public transport but could be working at home, may find themselves doing so right through until next spring rather than the autumn of this year," Laws  said.

“And I think we might also have to rethink the opening of some parts of the hospitality industry, given that it's more important that we have our education system back to normality than some of the other things that would be nice to do,” Laws  added.

Medley, the professor of infectious disease modelling at the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, said the restoration of lockdown measures in areas across the north-west of England last week were “highly unlikely” to be the last regional intervention.

He told Today, “I think we’re in a situation whereby most people think that opening schools is a priority for the health and wellbeing of children. And so actually, closing some of the other networks, some of the other activities may well be required to enable us to open schools.”

Medley added the current upsurge in coronavirus infections appeared to be among younger people but warned there was a danger it could “spill” over into other parts of the population.

“The age distribution of infections has changed, it has moved down into younger age groups and so it is likely we won’t see that increase in hospital admissions related to infection in the same way we did in March,” he said.

“But the big fear is the virus just gets out of control and we end up in a situation where there is so much virus that it inevitably spills out into all sections of the population,” he added.

Michie noted the government should be focusing more on the “isolate” strand of the “test, trace and isolate” system.

Independent Sage has long argued that an effective system must include financial support to reduce pressures to breach the 14-day period of isolation required of those identified as close contacts of coronavirus patients.

“The problem is that the government hasn’t got a strategy to support people to isolate,” she said.

“There are a lot of people who need financial support to be able to isolate. And there are a lot of people who can’t self-isolate at home because they are living in multi-generational families or overcrowded buildings,” she added.

She suggested England should learn from Vietnam, where coronavirus deaths were avoided altogether until the first fatality on Friday last week and where anyone who tests positive and their contacts are provided with accommodation to complete their isolation.

Thousands of hotel rooms lying empty could be used for those unable to isolate at home or those quarantining after arriving from abroad, she said.

“It seems expensive now, but it’s not if it means that within a matter of months we can properly reopen the economy,” she added, warning that Johnson’s whack-a-mole strategy of clamping down on local flare-ups means an unpredictable cycle of relaxations and restrictions.

“There are going to be other Leicesters,” she said, adding, “Businesses want certainty and predictability, they don’t want to be opening up to shut down again.

“What the government should be trying to do in England is what Scotland and Ireland are doing and that is going for zero COVID - eliminating any community transmission and getting a good test-and-trace system in place before the winter flu season, because that allows us to jump on any local outbreaks quickly and use quarantine at the borders to stop new seeding events," she underlined.

“Otherwise it’s potentially going to be very problematic,” she underscored.

 

 

 

 

 

Bottom top
Spain: Protesters Call for End to Spanish Monarchy after Former King's Exit

TEHRAN (FNA)- Protesters on Sunday called for an end to the Spanish monarchy after the sudden departure of the former king Juan Carlos from the country this week amid a corruption scandal. [VIDEO]
Lebanon: Burned Out Vehicles, Damaged Buildings in Aftermath of Beirut Riot

TEHRAN (FNA)- Destroyed shops and vehicles were seen in Central Beirut on Sunday in the aftermath of a night of clashes between dozens of rioters and the police. [VIDEO]
Palestinians Stand in Solidarity with Lebanon

TEHRAN (FNA)- Palestinians in Gaza attend a vigil to stand in solidarity with Lebanon after deadly blast in capital Beirut. [PHOTOS]
Global COVID-19 cases surpass 20 million

TEHRAN (FNA)- Global cases of COVID-19 have surpassed 20 million, increasing by ten million in just 43 days. [PHOTOS]
Iran’s Judiciary to File Lawsuit against Brian Hook

TEHRAN (FNA)- Iran’s Deputy Judiciary Chief for International Affairs Ali Baqeri called on the country’s prosecutor to lodge a complaint against former US special representative for Iran Brian Hook for his hostile measures and threatening the Iranian military officials with assassination.
Violent Protesters Continue Riot in Lebanon for 2nd Night

TEHRAN (FNA)- Small groups of protesters went out for a second night and clashed with the police near several government premises in Beirut.
Deputy FM Blasts Forged PGCC’s Letter to UN on Extension of Arms Embargos against Iran

TEHRAN (FNA)- Iranian Deputy Foreign Minister for Legal and International Affairs Mohsen Baharvand lashed out at certain members of the Persian Gulf Cooperation Council for forging a letter to the UN Security Council on behalf of other PGCC countries on extension of arms embargos against Tehran.
Syrian Tribe Declares Popular War Against US Forces, SDF

TEHRAN (FNA)- A Syrian tribe in the Eastern province of Deir Ezzur launched a popular resistance force against US troops and their allies, accusing the so-called Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF) of stealing the country’s resources.
Lawyer: Venezuela Granted Full Leave to Appeal UK Ruling Denying Access to Gold Reserves

TEHRAN (FNA)- The Venezuelan Central Bank (BCV) has been given the right to appeal all aspects of an original ruling by a UK court that denied Caracas custody of Venezuelan gold reserves that are currently being held by the Bank of England, a lawyer said on Monday.
IRGC Deputy Commander: No US Official Valuable Enough to Be General Soleimani's Direct Ransom for Revenge

TEHRAN (FNA)- Islamic Revolution Guards Corps Deputy Commander for Political Affairs Brigadier General Yadollah Javani said that no US official is valuable enough to be targeted as a direct ransom for the assassination of the martyred IRGC Quds Force Commander, Lieutenant General Qassem Soleimani.
Iran-Afghanistan-Uzbekistan Transit Corridor Goes into Operation

TEHRAN (FNA)- Iran put the pilot project of Iran-Afghanistan-Uzbekistan transit corridor into operation, as two trucks started on Monday transporting goods from Iran to Afghanistan and finally to Uzbekistan.
Ambassador: New US Representative for Iran Showing Trump’s Confusion

TEHRAN (FNA)- Iranian Ambassador to Venezuela Hojjatollah Soltani said that the new US special representative for the Islamic Republic of Iran indicates President Donald Trump's bewilderment.
Looting, Rioting Breaks Out in Chicago After Police Shooting

TEHRAN (FNA)- Large scale protests and unrest broke out in Chicago, including mass looting taking place across the city.
UK to Plunge into Deepest Slump on Record with Worst GDP Drop of G7

TEHRAN (FNA)- Britain’s economy will be officially declared in recession this week for the first time since the 2008 financial crisis, as the coronavirus outbreak plunges the country into the deepest slump on record.
UK PM Insists Schools Safe Hours After Children’s Commissioner Calls for More Testing

TEHRAN (FNA)- UK Prime Minister Boris Johnson insisted schools are safe to re-open next month just hours after the Children’s Commissioner called for routine coronavirus testing for pupils and teachers.