Medicine
Tue Jun 02, 2020 4:6
Statistics Watchdog: UK Ministers Still Misleading Public on Coronavirus Tests
TEHRAN (FNA)- The head of the UK Statistics Authority accused the government of continuing to mislead the public over the numbers of tests carried out for COVID-19.

 “The aim seems to be to show the largest possible number of tests, even at the expense of understanding,” said David Norgrove in a letter to the Health Secretary, Matt Hancock, The Guardian reported.

He upbraids the government for mixing up tests carried out with testing kits sent out by post.

“This distinction is too often elided during the presentation at the daily press conference, where the relevant figure may misleadingly be described simply as the number of tests carried out. There are no data on how many of the tests posted out are in fact then successfully completed,” he says in his letter.

Norgrove has a number of other criticisms of the way testing is carried out and the data presented to the public. His letter is a second attempt to get more clarification from the government.

On May 11, he asked for more detail of the plans for 200,000 tests to be carried out in England every day. It should be clear whether the target referred to testing capacity, the tests that have been administered, the test results received or the number of people tested, he wrote.

Hancock replied, welcoming Norgrove’s comments, saying he was publishing details of how the 200,000 tests would be counted.

“The programme is committed to being as transparent as possible about its work,” said Hancock.

Dido Harding, who had taken over its leadership, “is keen to engage with you on how we ensure the right statistical reporting of the test and trace programme as it develops”, he wrote.

But Norgrove’s latest letter to the health secretary makes clear that his doubts have not been allayed.

Statistics on testing serve two purposes, he writes.

“The first is to help us understand the epidemic, alongside the ONS survey, showing us how many people are infected, or not, and their relevant characteristics," he said.

“The second purpose is to help manage the test programme, to ensure there are enough tests, that they are carried out or sent where they are needed and that they are being used as effectively as possible. The data should tell the public how effectively the testing programme is being managed, he added.

“The way the data are analysed and presented currently gives them limited value for the first purpose. The aim seems to be to show the largest possible number of tests, even at the expense of understanding. It is also hard to believe the statistics work to support the testing programme itself. The statistics and analysis serve neither purpose well,” Norgrove said.

As well as the confusion between tests carried out and tests posted, Norgrove says it is not clear from the data how often people are tested twice. He objects that the data is presented in a way that is hard to understand.

“Many of the key numbers make little sense without recourse to the technical notes, which are themselves sometimes hard to follow,” he writes.

On Monday, the Department of Health and Social Care tweeted that so far 4,484,340 tests had been carried out, with 128,437 tests done on Sunday May 31– well short of the 200,000 ambition. A total of 276,332 people have tested positive.

 

 

 

 

Bottom top
Iran's Beautiful Places, Holy Sites

TEHRAN (FNA)- The cultural sites of Iran are all not just filled with a rich history, but also burst with colorful tiles and fascinating feats of engineering. [PHOTOS]
US: SUV Plows Through Protesters in New York City

TEHRAN (FNA)- A shocking scene of an SUV plowing through protesters in New York City was caught on film on Tuesday evening. A bicycle was dragged for more than a block but the cyclist was not seriously injured. The driver of the SUV was taken into custody. [VIDEO]
Lebanon: Hezbollah Supporters Rally Against Visit of US Central Command Chief

TEHRAN (FNA)- Dozens of demonstrators gathered in Beirut on Wednesday to protest against the visit of US Central Command chief General Kenneth McKenzie to Lebanon. The protesters could be seen waving Hezbollah flags and chanting against alleged US interference on internal affairs. [VIDEO]
US: Inside Hard-Hit Houston as Coronavirus Cases Surge

TEHRAN (FNA)- In Houston, one of the nation's fastest-growing coronavirus hot spots, more residents are dying before they can make it to a hospital. [PHOTOS]
Rescuers Scramble to Reach Thousands Trapped by Floods

TEHRAN (FNA)- Japanese emergency services and troops scrambled on Thursday to reach thousands of homes cut off by catastrophic flooding and landslides that have killed dozens and caused widespread damage. [PHOTOS]
UK: Crane Collapses into Building in East London

TEHRAN (FNA)- A woman has died after a crane collapsed on to two terraced houses in ٍast London. London fire brigade said she had been found on the first floor of one of the houses in Bow and had been confirmed dead at the scene. Crews had been searching the houses as part of a complex rescue operation after the 20-metre-high crane fell at 2.39pm on 7 July. [VIDEO]
Syria: Residents Struggle after Turkish Forces Cut Water to Hasakah

TEHRAN (FNA)- Turkish forces have reportedly halted operations at the Aluk water station, which supplies the Syrian city of Hasakah and the surrounding area, for the seventh time since they took control of the station in the Northern countryside of Hasakah. [VIDEO]
US: Vigil Held in Brooklyn, NY for Victims of Gun Violence

TEHRAN (FNA)- Family members of the victims of violent crimes gather at Brooklyn Borough Hall for a vigil against gun violence in the Brooklyn borough of New York City. 101 pairs of shoes and a casket are laid out at the steps of Brooklyn's borough hall to represent the 101 shooting victims in the 74 gun violence incidents that have taken place over the past week throughout the city. [PHOTOS]
Serbia Protests Meet Violent Response in Europe’s 1st Major Virus Unrest

TEHRAN (FNA)- Thousands of Serbs demonstrated for a second consecutive night on Wednesday in response to President Aleksandar Vucic’s management of the coronavirus crisis and wider concerns over the state of democracy in Serbia. [PHOTOS]
Poll Finds Nine Out of 10 Americans Say Racism, Police Brutality Are Problems

TEHRAN (FNA)- Nine in 10 Americans believe that racism and police violence are problems in the country, a Guardian/Opinium Research poll found, a sign that public opinion is shifting away from the views put forward by President Donald Trump.
Report: Attacks Against Journalists Soar During Black Lives Matter Protests in US

TEHRAN (FNA)- At least 50 journalists in the US have been arrested during Black Lives Matter demonstrations across the US, while dozens of others have also been injured by rubber bullets, pepper spray and tear gas.
Energy Minister: 227 Water, Electricity Projects Inaugurated in Iran in 6 Months

TEHRAN (FNA)- Iranian Energy Minister Reza Ardakanian said that the country inaugurated 227 water and electricity projects in the second half of the last Iranian year (ended on March 19).
Iran Stresses Determination to Develop Strategic Ties with China

TEHRAN (FNA)- Iranian Foreign Ministry Spokesman Seyed Abbas Mousavi stressed that Tehran and Beijing are determined to further expand their strategic relations.
Iranian President Inaugurates Several Infrastructural Projects

TEHRAN (FNA)- Iranian President Hassan Rouhani on Thursday inaugurated several infrastructural projects in the Central, Southeastern and Southern parts of the country despite the US pressures and sanctions.
Spokesman Rejects US "Lies" about Confiscation of Iranian Ship Carrying Arms to Yemen

TEHRAN (FNA)- Iran's Foreign Ministry Spokesman Seyed Abbbas Mousavi dismissed the US claims about seizing an Iranian ship carrying weapons to Yemen.